Why we snack, and how to take back control

It's evening. You get in, the bag is barely down, dinner isn't ready, and your hand is already in the packet of crisps. You weren't even hungry on the stairs. That's the strange thing about snacking: it often turns up without warning and without real hunger, and yet you end up holding an empty packet, feeling slightly guilty. So how do you take back control?

It sounds obvious, but it isn't quite: to stop snacking you first have to decide to. Nobody can do that part for you. Willpower is personal — either you get that moment of resolve or you don't.

Once the decision has genuinely been made, there are some small tricks that make the job less of a slog, and the self-imposed deprivation a little easier to bear.

Look at your habits before you change anything

The first step, and not the smallest one: look at how you actually operate. When do you give in? Mid-morning, between breakfast and lunch? In the evening on the way home from work, just before sitting down to eat? Or after dinner, in front of the television, when boredom sets in? Ask yourself too under what conditions snacking happens — when you're upset, anxious, tired? And what your cravings pull you towards: sweet, salty, a bit of everything?

Young woman hesitating over a bowl of crisps on the sofa in the evening

We tend to snack without trying to understand it, tell ourselves it's bad, feel guilty, then start again the next day. Yet asking why, and in what circumstances, is the best way to find solutions that fit the way you function. It looks banal written down, but it really does change things.

If, for example, you notice that you mostly snack when you're bored, the answer isn't to force yourself into a sport you hate, but to organise activities you enjoy and that keep you occupied. When your attention is taken up, you simply stop thinking about food.

Three proper meals beat a day of grazing

And what if the cause were simpler than we think? If snacking without hunger is, for some people, pure habit, it's also possible to snack in response to hunger — without knowing how to stop. Two things to try here: organising your meals better, and leaning on foods that keep you fuller for longer. Plan in more protein and slow-release carbohydrates on the days you know will be long. That should head off cravings too early and give you the energy to get to the next meal.

Remember that three good meals a day are better than three small ones topped up with constant picking. In practice it's usually hunger doing the talking, not greed — it's just being given the wrong outlet.

It's also worth fitting your daily routine to your body's rhythm. A typical example: you always snack on the way home from work while dinner is cooking. No wonder — you're hungry and can't wait any longer. The answer is sometimes very small: preparing meals ahead, so that everything is ready when you get in and all that's left is to reheat it and sit down.

Small bowls of dried fruit and nuts on a linen cloth

A craving passes if you give it time

Feeling peckish? Wait a moment. Cravings often go as quickly as they arrive, especially when you aren't genuinely hungry. You suddenly think about a square of chocolate, about something that appeals, and your hand moves on its own. So rather than heading straight for the sweet cupboard, breathe, do something else, and watch: the urge usually fades.

Genuinely hungry and giving in? Then choose the right foods, the ones that blunt hunger and still earn their place nutritionally: dried fruit and nuts, an apple, a banana, wholemeal bread, raw vegetables to crunch. Have a cup of tea or some flavoured water — and while you're at it, swap the chocolate bar you always carry at the bottom of your bag for a decent-sized apple and a bottle of water. Your bag will weigh a few grams more; your afternoon will feel lighter.

Hands filling a shopping bag with an apple, a banana and a bottle of water

Eat — but actually eat

Another rule of the anti-snacking repertoire, and not the least: when you eat, do only that. Nothing is worse than meals swallowed in front of the television or in a noisy room. You stop paying attention to what you're eating, so you miss the fullness signal. You don't enjoy it, you eat more and faster, stressed by everything around you.

Eat slowly, chew properly and focus on the flavours and on what's on your plate. It sounds silly, but fullness takes time to register in the brain — so give it the chance.

Which brings us to a question we often dodge: why do we give in? If you tend to snack because you're stressed, anxious or frustrated, it's about learning to manage your emotions and your stress, and about finding what genuinely helps you. Exercise, relaxation, walks, breathing exercises, acupuncture — it's a question of finding what works for you. But knowing the pitfalls of stress already makes you more watchful: you know that when you're tense you snack, so before reaching for biscuits or crisps, ask yourself whether that's really what you need at that moment, or whether you're compensating for something else. And if stress takes up too much room in your daily life, do talk to your GP — without making that your only route.

Allow yourself a real treat, without the guilt

It may sound paradoxical, but you also need to treat yourself. Nothing is worse than frustration and foods you ban outright. You've probably noticed it: you deny yourself your favourite treat and eat an apple instead. It may have taken the edge off your hunger, but not the desire for fat or sugar. The result is that you're frustrated, so you eat a second thing from the 'low-calorie' category, then a third — and, ironically, you often end up giving in to the very thing you wanted in the first place. Which means a heavy tally for a pleasure you didn't even savour.

So allow yourself small treats from time to time: if they stay reasonable, they shouldn't affect your waistline. Where these treats are concerned, either buy them occasionally, one at a time, or go for small packs so you're limited to one portion. Because the three-for-two packs you were keeping 'for later' are quite likely to bring on a few regrets before the week is out.

Two squares of dark chocolate broken on a small stoneware plate

That said, everyone knows it: snacking is also a habit to unlearn. It's hard at first, with a few relapses, because the body reflexively asks for that sweet, comforting ritual. But once the habit is settled you can do without it — and it can help you feel better in your body, with no guarantee of results, which is encouraging enough in itself.

In practice, when a craving strikes: drink a large glass of water, go for a five-minute walk, or start a small task that keeps your hands busy. The urge often subsides after a few minutes — a sign that it wasn't real hunger.

Budget

Alternatives to snacking are entirely affordable, provided you look at where the products come from. Allow roughly £2 to £5 per kilo for seasonal fruit, and nearer £15 to £30 per kilo for plain nuts — almonds, walnuts, hazelnuts — which cost more by weight but are eaten in smaller quantities. Loose-leaf tea or herbal infusions generally come in at around £4 to £12 per 100 g. Prices shift with the season, the label (organic or not), where you buy (supermarket, market, health-food shop, online order) and whether you buy loose or in bulk; buying only what you need is still the best way of not finishing the packet out of pure habit.

Sources