You open the chiller door and three packs look almost identical: tofu, tempeh, seitan. They all boast protein, and they all promise to stand in for meat. But behind the label they have almost nothing in common — not the base ingredient, not the texture, not the salt content, not the way you cook them. So how do you tell them apart without picking the wrong one?

Three foods, three jobs

Plain tofu first. It is a curd made from soya milk, produced a little like fresh cheese. Firm tofu holds its shape in a frying pan and survives a slow cooker without falling apart; silken tofu is better for sauces, creams and desserts. It is the chameleon of the trio: it has almost no flavour of its own, so it takes on whatever you give it — a huge advantage, as long as you season it properly. And it is not just the plain block: on the shelf you will also find smoked tofu, perfect cold in salads or wraps with no cooking, and marinated tofu, which needs about five minutes in a pan for busy evenings.

Tempeh, next, is whole fermented soya. It has a dense texture, an uneven surface and a faint nutty note. It holds up very well in cooking and works beautifully with punchy sauces. Seitan is a different thing entirely: it is made from wheat gluten, not soya. Dense, chewy and very high in protein, it is already cooked when you buy it. One caution: it should be avoided if you have coeliac disease or a gluten sensitivity.

Three ceramic bowls with cubed tofu, sliced tempeh and shredded seitan
Cubed, sliced or shredded: each one calls for a different approach

What the ingredients list tells you

A good plain tofu has a short ingredients list: soya, water and a coagulant — magnesium chloride or calcium sulphate. If calcium sulphate is used, the product may also provide calcium, which is worth checking if you are cutting back on dairy.

Next, look at the salt line in the nutrition table, per 100g. The ANSES Ciqual table lets you compare foods side by side, and the results are often revealing. In practice, marinated, smoked and breaded versions are often saltier than the plain block. The same goes for fat: a breadcrumb coating and a trip through hot oil push up the fat content, so the food can be far more calorie-dense than it looks.

Soya beans, water, coagulant and a block of fresh tofu on a light worktop
Soya, water, coagulant: a plain tofu needs only three lines

One thing to keep in mind: as Agence BIO points out, organic labels (AB, the EU leaf) guarantee a ban on GMOs and restricted pesticide use in farming. They say nothing about salt content or how processed the food is. These are separate questions, and an organic product can very well be high in salt.

Texture and the basic technique

What goes wrong most often is not the product but the technique. And there is no mystery here: three habits are enough to turn a bland block into something you want to eat again.

Press it. Tofu comes out of the pack waterlogged. Leave it to drain for fifteen minutes between two plates or in a clean tea towel: that way it browns instead of steaming.

Brown it. Get the pan hot, add a little oil, then turn the heat to medium. Add the pieces and leave them alone for a few minutes. That crust is what transforms it.

Season it. Marinade barely penetrates a compact block. Instead, focus on coating it: soy sauce, nutritional yeast, spices, lemon, before or during cooking. For tempeh, a five-minute simmer before cooking softens its bitterness — a small step that changes the plate. Seitan is already cooked: you just warm it through, brown it and serve it.

Young woman in a kitchen wrapping a block of tofu in a clean cloth to drain it
The step that transforms it: press tofu well before browning

Fridge test: an unopened plain tofu will keep until the date on the pack. Once opened, store it in a jar of clean water in the fridge, changing the water regularly, and eat it soon. Tempeh and seitan keep for less time once opened, so it is best to use them quickly, while respecting the date on the pack.

Budget

Prices vary a lot depending on where you shop, the brand, whether it is organic and the pack size. As a rough guide, expect to pay around:

  • Plain tofu: £6–12/kg in supermarkets, £10–18/kg in health food shops;
  • Smoked or marinated tofu: £12–25/kg;
  • Tempeh: £15–30/kg;
  • Seitan: £12–25/kg;
  • Breaded versions: £12–25/kg, with a higher fat content.

Where to find them? The chilled plant-based aisle in supermarkets, where the range has expanded a lot in recent years, health food shops and veg box schemes or farm shops, and Asian grocers, where plain tofu is often the cheapest by weight — as long as you check the origin and salt content. Tempeh is still rare on shelves, so buying online is a useful fallback.

One health note: as French public health nutrition guidelines from Santé publique France remind us, these foods belong in a diet rich in vegetables and fibre, but they do not do the work for you. If you have a soya allergy, a kidney condition or coeliac disease, speak to a health professional before changing your diet — this is something to manage with support, not a solo adjustment.

There you have it: three formats now clearer in your mind, and hopefully no more mixing them up. The next test? A block of plain tofu, well pressed, and a hot pan — see what happens. One thing is certain: cooked well, all three deserve their place in the fridge — not as a fallback, but as proper ingredients in their own right.

Sources