You’re standing in the aisle with a sachet of plant powder in one hand and a box dye in the other. On one side, the idea of putting pigments from plants, chamomile, henna or tea on your scalp. On the other, the promise of a perfectly controlled platinum blonde. And that small voice asking: what if natural isn’t as gentle as it sounds? It’s a fair question, and it deserves a proper answer.

Research on the subject isn’t unanimous, but chemical hair dyes are suspected of causing plenty of harm. Carcinogenic, mutagenic and even teratogenic — meaning they may cause malformations in an embryo — these are frightening risks, even if they haven’t been officially proven. So with organic and natural products back in fashion, it’s no surprise that plant-based hair dyes are getting fresh attention.

Close-up of glossy chestnut-brown hair with copper tones and a little plant-based paste

The “green” trap on the label

Some dyes marketed as natural do contain chemical precursors such as paraphenylenediamine (PPD) and an oxidising agent. The only reliable arbiter is the INCI list on the back of the pack. If you spot PPD, it’s a conventional dye dressed up in green packaging. That’s not an accusation, just a close read that can save you a lot of disappointment.

An editorial comparison of plant powders and a box dye, with an out-of-focus INCI list

Nor does “plant-based” automatically mean “very gentle”. Some pure plant dyes, henna in particular, bind to keratin and can leave a film; how well they are tolerated varies with the plant, the preparation and the person. These formulas contain no ammonia and no added oxidising agent, but that doesn’t mean they suit every scalp. The one step worth taking before you even mix the powder is a patch test on a small area of skin, 48 hours beforehand.

What they can do, and what they can’t

The flip side, of course, is that they don’t allow the same flights of fancy as their chemical counterparts. With natural dyes, there’s no radical colour change and little or no lightening: they mainly add tone and reflection, and can make hair slightly darker. On coverage, even though natural colours have improved a great deal, they still don’t cover as thoroughly as chemical dyes.

They will still tint grey hair, but those strands will stay lighter than the rest. That said, the reflections and tones these plant pigments give are lovely, and they have the advantage of staying in harmony with each person’s natural complexion. Note too that these natural colorants can, for some people, give a shinier look or a feeling of thickness, but they do not treat the hair and they don’t suit everyone.

Three-quarter rear view of a young mixed-heritage woman with brown hair scattered with grey and a copper-toned sheen

Also, while they fade with each wash, the effect remains harmonious and helps limit regrowth lines. How long they last depends on the plant and the process: some plant dyes fade within a few weeks, while henna can last much longer. Be aware that applying a natural dye takes longer than a chemical one. You need to respect that development time if you want a clearly visible result.

Mixing the two

It’s advisable to leave a gap between applying a natural colour and a chemical one, in either direction. In every case, read the instructions: they’ll tell you what precautions to take. And if you later want to go back to salon colour, tell your stylist that you’ve used a natural dye and what type — whether it contained chamomile, henna, tea, boxwood and so on.

Some substances used in chemical dyes, such as PPD, can cause severe allergic reactions; ammonia and peroxide can irritate or weaken the hair. Their use is regulated, and the risks vary according to the product and the person. Of course, chemical dyes have advantages: they let us indulge all sorts of whims, from a radical colour change to going from flaxen blonde to raven black, or the other way round. They are, unquestionably, effective.

But they also contain, among other things, ammonia, peroxide or paraphenylenediamine: it’s better to read the instructions, follow the precautions and do a patch test before you start — which is sometimes reason enough to choose a plant-based dye, without expecting the same result. The verdict: yes, plant-based colour has every right to a place in your bathroom, as long as you accept its limits.

Before applying any hair colour, a patch test on a small area of skin 48 hours beforehand is the step most likely to save you from unpleasant surprises — especially when you don’t yet know exactly what’s in the product.

Budget

On price, it all depends on the formula and where you buy it. A henna or plant-based dye powder to mix yourself usually costs around £5–£15 a sachet, not counting any aftercare. For a ready-to-use kit, expect more like £10–£25. In a salon, plant-based colour usually sits between £40 and £90, and more for long hair or a blended finish; it’s worth asking for a quote before you settle into the chair. The price also varies with the brand, organic certification and the type of plants used.

Sources

  • Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on cosmetic products, which governs hair colorants.
  • ANSES, the French national agency for food, environmental and occupational health and safety, publications on hair dyes.
  • SCCS (Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety), opinions on hair colorants.