Guerlain Eye Liner

When it comes to reliable liners, this little Guerlain bottle is hard to beat. It looks polished and is genuinely practical, and the formula is excellent. The ultra-fine brush gives a precise, delicate line; the shades are intense, staying power is excellent and, contrary to what you might expect, one bottle lasts a good while, even with daily use.

Yes, it costs a fair amount, and comes in several shades, but it is an investment you will not regret, or so say the converts.

Black liquid liner bottle with an ultra-fine brush on a pale marble shelf
The slim bottle and ultra-fine brush for a millimetre-precise line

Shiseido Khol Crème Relief

A kohl-and-eyeliner hybrid in a cream texture, sold in a small pot with its own brush. Like many Shiseido products, the quality is there: a soft cream texture with deep colour and very good staying power. It applies easily, even for beginners, and lets you vary your look — thicker or thinner, a fine line or a smudgy charcoal eye, whichever you fancy.

One or two tries to get the hang of it, especially if you are used to liquid liner, and you are away: easy to apply, it does not run, it is easy to control how much you use and the little pot lasts a good while.

Open small pot of black cream kohl with its brush on a bright bathroom counter
The little cream kohl pot and brush, easy enough for beginners

Chanel Duo Eyeliner Professionnel

Chanel offers an eyeliner in compact form: a small case with two shades, one black and one slightly pearlescent anthracite, so you can vary your make-up to suit your mood.

Inside are two brushes that slot together for easier handling, with a sponge tip for smudging and a brush tip for a fine line.

What we like: the cream textures, which are easy to apply, and the two tips, which make a smoky eye incredibly easy or let you apply liner in the usual way. Note that the brush needs dampening before use for a really precise application and a line that lasts.

The catch is the price: it is the most expensive set in our selection.

Open compact with two cream eyeliner shades and two slot-together brushes
The duo compact: deep black, pearlescent anthracite, two tips

Clarins Eyeliner Express

A basic, effective eyeliner from Clarins: a pen with a brush tip. Fluid texture, intense colours, a fine brush that is easy to use, good staying power. It is the eyeliner that gets straight to the point, and convinces.

Available in black and brown, and practical with it.

Black brush-tip eyeliner pen beside a small mirror on pale linen
The brush-tip pen, in black or brown, ready in one stroke

MAC Fluidline Eye-liner Gel

What do we like? Almost everything! The cream texture is very pleasant and easy to apply, and the colours are intense — and very varied, with several shades for bespoke looks, whether basic or colourful.

We like the compact little pot and the range of lines the brush allows: fine or thick, kohl or liner, however you want it. Staying power is very good and the product lasts a long time: it is proper MAC, professional to the end.

A small gripe: the glass pot, so mind you do not drop it. And it is not always easy to find, since MAC stores are not on every corner. That said, you can buy it from the brand's online store, though you lose the counter assistant's advice and a clear sense of the shades.

Glass pot of gel eyeliner, lid open, with a fine brush on a dark counter
The glass gel pot: long wear and a precise brush

A good eyeliner is something of a Holy Grail for anyone who loves a feline flick. The fact is, smoky make-up — a heavy lid of kohl, mascara and deep-toned shadows — still has its devotees. That said, a neat eyeliner flick over a neutral powdered lid is also a timeless look: feminine and elegant without being showy.

Yes, eyeliner looks beautiful simply paired with a touch of mascara or as part of a more elaborate make-up, but you still need to know how to apply it. That is where the quality of the liner comes in: there is no way around it, you need practice even with the Rolls-Royce of eyeliners, but a good-quality eyeliner is already half the battle.

The move that makes all the difference: rest your elbow on the table to steady your hand, hold the lid taut with a fingertip, start at the middle and work outwards before going back to the inner corner — inner corner last, always. And take up very little product: better to go over it twice than overload in one go.

Budget

As a rough guide, a branded eyeliner tends to cost around £20 to £45 in the UK, depending on format and brand; check current prices. Based on prices seen, the Clarins pen remains the most accessible option, the MAC gel pot is in the same league, while the Guerlain and Chanel bottles and compacts push the total higher. The price also depends on the number of shades and brushes included. You will find them at department store beauty counters, brand boutiques or online.